top of page

The Things Leaders Shouldn't Say ... but we are anyway.

Writer: Crystal Watson
Crystal Watson
1 day ago
8 min read

Updated: 2 hours ago

Listen to Crystal Read it AloudDr. Crystal Watson
Because apparently, the truth becomes a problem when it comes from the person in charge.

There’s an unwritten rule in educational leadership.

Actually, there are several.

Don’t question the decisions made above you.

Don’t admit when you’re overwhelmed.

Don’t tell teachers how frustrated you are with the very system you’re expected to defend.

Don’t say the initiative or directive is ridiculous.

Don’t acknowledge that sometimes the people making the decisions are the furthest removed from the people living with the consequences.

And for the love of everything holy…

Don’t EVER say you’re tired of the BS.

Because leaders are supposed to be composed.

Professional.

Strategic.

Diplomatic.

We’re supposed to smile through dysfunction, translate nonsense into actionable steps, and somehow convince everybody that the latest thing being thrown at us is exactly what we’ve been missing.

We’re supposed to be the calm in the storm.

Even when we’re standing in the middle of a hurricane we didn’t create but must attempt to withstand.  

SOMETIMES THE PEOPLE MAKING THE DECISIONS DON’T KNOW WHAT THEY’RE DOING.

There.

I said it.

And before somebody starts clutching their pearls, let’s be clear.

This isn’t about disrespecting district leadership, executive teams, or policymakers. I know some personally that really do great work and stay close to the ground. 

It’s about acknowledging a dangerous reality in education:

Authority does not automatically equal expertise.

Some decisions are made in rooms where the people most impacted by those decisions don’t have a seat.

Not the teachers.

Not the principals.

Not the students.

Not the families…. Especially those that are not the loudest.

But somehow, those same people are expected to make the decisions work.

And when they don’t?

We call it an implementation problem.

We question leadership capacity.

We demand stronger accountability.

We schedule another meeting.

We build another tracking sheet.

But rarely do we ask whether the decision itself was flawed.

Here’s what leaders aren’t supposed to say:

Sometimes the problem isn’t implementation. Sometimes the plan was trash from the beginning.

And no amount of professional development, coaching, or monitoring is going to turn a fundamentally disconnected decision into meaningful change.

We have to stop confusing compliance with progress.

WE’RE TIRED OF BEING HELD ACCOUNTABLE FOR THINGS WE DON’T HAVE THE AUTHORITY TO CHANGE.

Let’s talk about the impossible position of school-level leadership.

Principals are expected to improve student achievement.

Fix school culture.

Retain teachers.

Manage parent concerns.

Address student behavior.

Implement district initiatives.

Monitor instruction.

Respond to crises.

Build relationships.

And somehow maintain a healthy school community.

All while operating within systems that were not really made for the students and communities in which some of us work. 

Staffing allocations?

Not always our decision. Almost never, actually. 

Budget restrictions?

Often predetermined. And, who asks what we are willing to give up BEFORE making cuts? I’ll wait…. 

Curriculum mandates?

Already decided.

A million assessments? 

Yup. 

But when the results don’t meet expectations?

Guess whose leadership gets questioned.

Accountability without authority isn’t leadership development. It’s a setup.

And the most frustrating part?

We’re often expected to absorb the consequences quietly.

To figure it out.

To make it work.

To be resourceful.

To be resilient.

“Remember our why!” makes me want to break something. 

But at what point do we stop celebrating leaders for surviving impossible conditions and start questioning why those conditions exist?

Because resilience should not be the price of admission to educational leadership.

SOMETIMES WE DON’T BELIEVE IN THE THING WE’RE BEING ASKED TO SELL.

Now THIS is the one that makes people uncomfortable.

Because educational leaders are expected to demonstrate alignment.

We’re expected to communicate a unified message.

We’re expected to champion the vision.

Even when we weren’t invited to help create it.

Even when we raised concerns.

Even when we know the timing is terrible.

Even when our teachers are already drowning.

And here’s the part nobody wants to acknowledge:

Sometimes leaders are forced to become the public relations department for decisions they privately disagree with.

This is hard, ya’ll. 

We stand in front of our teams and try to find the value.

We search for the connection.

We soften the language.

We make the PowerPoint.

We facilitate the meeting.

And then we go back to our offices wondering how much more credibility we can spend defending decisions we didn’t make.

Because every time we ask teachers to trust us, we’re drawing from a relationship we’ve worked hard to build.

And trust?

Trust is expensive.

Here’s the truth:

Being a team player should not require abandoning your professional judgment.

And loyalty to an organization should never demand dishonesty with the people you lead.

WE LOVE OUR STAFF, AND WE ARE EXHAUSTED

Whew.

Now we’re really getting into it.

Because leaders aren’t supposed to say this.

We’re supposed to love our teams unconditionally.

Support everybody.

Understand everybody.

Extend grace.

Listen.

Coach.

Encourage.

Empower.

And yes, all of that matters.

But can we acknowledge something?

Leading adults is HARD.

Sometimes the resistance is unreasonable.

Sometimes the negativity is contagious.

Sometimes people demand accountability for everybody except themselves.

Sometimes the very people asking for transparency struggle when transparency requires them to confront their own practices.

And sometimes…

You’re just tired of having the same conversation for the seventeenth time.

Like, how many times must we reiterate directives that will HELP but continue to see a refusal to implement? 

That doesn’t mean you don’t care.

It doesn’t mean you’re a bad leader.

It means you’re human.

And here’s something else we’re not supposed to say:

Not every problem in a school is a leadership problem. Sometimes adults have to take responsibility for the energy, effort, and professionalism they bring into the building.

A healthy school culture is not something a principal creates alone.

It is something an entire community must be willing to build.

And maintain.

Together.

SOMETIMES WE GO HOME AND WONDER IF ANY OF THIS IS ACTUALLY MAKING A DIFFERENCE.

This one isn’t funny.

This one is personal.

Because behind the titles, degrees, evaluations, leadership meetings, and strategic plans…

There are people.

People who care deeply.

People who entered education believing they could change lives.

People who still believe schools can be places of possibility.

But some days?

The weight is heavy.

You spend your entire day solving problems.

You make decisions that affect children, families, and livelihoods.

You navigate conflict.

You absorb frustration.

You carry information you cannot share.

You celebrate everybody else’s wins.

And then you go home.

And wonder…

Did I do enough today?

Did I make the right decision?

Did I advocate hard enough?

Did I protect my teachers?

Did I fail a child?

Did I miss something important?

And perhaps the hardest question of all:

Am I becoming the kind of leader I once promised myself I would never be?

Because somewhere between surviving the demands of the job and meeting the expectations of the system, it’s possible to lose pieces of yourself.

Your creativity.

Your courage.

Your voice.

Your joy.

And that’s a conversation we don’t have nearly enough.

WE DON’T WANT TO BE RESILIENT ANYMORE. WE WANT THINGS TO CHANGE.

Can we retire from the constant celebration of resilience for just a moment?

Because education has become incredibly skilled at applauding people for enduring conditions we should be working to eliminate.

We celebrate principals who work twelve-hour days.

We praise teachers who sacrifice their planning periods.

We honor educators who spend their own money.

We call people superheroes when they consistently do the work of three people.

And then we wonder why people are exhausted.

We have normalized dysfunction and renamed it dedication.

Read that again.

We have normalized dysfunction.

And renamed it dedication.

The problem isn’t that educators lack commitment.

The problem is that commitment has too often become an excuse to demand more without providing what people need.

More initiatives.

More documentation.

More monitoring.

More meetings.

More expectations.

But not necessarily more time.

More support.

More resources.

Or more trust.

At some point, we have to stop asking educators how much more they can carry.

And start asking why we keep adding weight.

WE CAN BE GOOD LEADERS AND STILL DISAGREE WITH THE SYSTEM WE WORK IN.

Somewhere along the way, educational leadership became tangled up with the expectation of unquestioned loyalty.

But let’s be clear.

Disagreement is not disloyalty.

Questioning a decision is not insubordination.

Naming a problem is not negativity.

And refusing to pretend something is working when it isn’t?

That just might be integrity.

The best leaders aren’t necessarily the ones who agree with everything.

Sometimes they’re the ones willing to ask the question everybody else is avoiding.

Sometimes they’re the ones willing to challenge the narrative.

Sometimes they’re the ones willing to say:

“This isn’t working.”

“Our teachers deserve better.”

“Our students need something different.”

“We need to rethink this.”

And sometimes…

“No. We’re not doing that to our people.”

Because leadership isn’t just about managing expectations.

It’s about exercising judgment.

It’s about protecting the conditions necessary for meaningful learning.

It’s about having the courage to challenge practices that undermine the very outcomes we claim to value.

And it’s about remembering that our responsibility to children must remain bigger than our desire to appear agreeable.



THE COST OF SILENCE

Here’s what concerns me most.

We’ve created a culture in education where leaders are often rewarded for how well they manage the appearance of success.

I’ve personally watched and heard leaders outright lie about what they’re doing in order to maintain a facade. It’s frustrating for those of us that are truthful and it’s sad to watch. 

I digress… 

Leaders are often judged on 

How polished the presentation looks.

How confidently they communicate the plan.

How quickly they respond.

How effectively they maintain order.

But what happens when maintaining the appearance of success requires us to remain silent about the conditions preventing it?

What happens when leaders become so skilled at managing the narrative that they stop challenging the reality?

What happens when we mistake silence for professionalism?

Because silence has a cost.

And that cost is often paid by the very people we claim to serve.

Teachers lose trust.

Leaders lose themselves.

Students inherit systems that remain unchanged.

And everybody keeps showing up to meetings pretending we don’t know what the real problems are.

That’s not leadership. That’s performance.

And education doesn’t need more performances.

It needs more truth.


SO LET ME SAY THIS…

I don’t believe educational leaders need permission to be human.

I don’t believe professionalism should require pretending.

I don’t believe protecting the system should matter more than protecting the people inside it.

And I certainly don’t believe that the most effective leaders are the ones who never make anybody uncomfortable.

Sometimes leadership requires discomfort.

Sometimes it requires difficult conversations.

Sometimes it requires acknowledging our own mistakes.

And sometimes it requires saying what everybody in the room knows but nobody wants to put on the record.

Not recklessly.

Not without thought.

Not without accountability.

But courageously.

Because there is a difference between being unprofessional and being unwilling to participate in professional silence.

And we need to stop pretending those are the same thing.

I can respect the work and still question the way we’re doing it.

I can love education and still be frustrated by the system.

I can lead with integrity and still admit that some days, this work is exhausting.

I can be committed without being consumed.

I can love where I work and still work to hold those within that place accountable - isn’t that what love is, anyway?! 

And perhaps most importantly…

I can be a leader without surrendering my voice.

That’s the kind of leadership conversation I’m interested in having.

Not the sanitized version.

Not the conference-friendly version.

Not the version carefully edited to make everybody comfortable.

The real one.

The messy one.

The one that acknowledges that leadership is complicated, people are human, and meaningful change requires more than another inspirational quote.

Because the truth is…

The things leaders aren’t supposed to say might be the very things education desperately needs to hear.

And if we’re serious about changing education, we have to be willing to talk about what isn’t working.

Even when it’s uncomfortable.

Especially when it’s uncomfortable.

NOW, I’M CURIOUS…

What’s one thing you’ve wanted to say as an educational leader but felt you couldn’t?

Not the politically correct answer.

Not the answer you’d give in a leadership meeting.

The REAL answer.

Because I know I’m not the only one who’s had to swallow a truth to keep the peace.

And maybe it’s time we stop swallowing so much.

SAY MORE.

Because the truth about leading in education deserves more than a whisper.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page